Contractors

CO₂ Sequestration Wells

Deep subsurface injection wells designed to permanently store captured carbon dioxide in target geological formations are referred to as CO₂ sequestration wells. Environmental liability at sequestration facilities can result from bore-integrity failures, improper injection pressures, and degradation of subsurface casing strings. Injected carbon streams may contain trace impurities, such as hydrogen sulfide, sulfur dioxide, and heavy hydrocarbons, which pose significant risks if not properly managed. Leakage around legacy wellbores, migration along active fault lines, and carbonic acid dissolution of caprock can lead to releases that contaminate drinking water aquifers, trigger induced seismicity, and vent gaseous emissions into the atmosphere. Sequestration operators may also engage in ancillary activities, such as high-pressure pipeline transport, surface fluid handling, and subsurface seismic monitoring, that may entail distinct environmental exposures.

Download PDF

Environmental Exposures May Include

Groundwater Acidification and Heavy Metal Mobilization
Brine Migration and Reservoir Displacement
Surface Atmospheric Releases and Gas Accumulation
Induced Seismicity and Fault Reactivation
Trace Impurity Releases

Groundwater Acidification and Heavy Metal Mobilization

Subsurface migration of injected CO₂ through degraded well casings, unsealed abandoned wells, or caprock fractures can breach shallow freshwater aquifers. Dissolved CO2 forms carbonic acid, lowering groundwater pH and leaching naturally occurring heavy metals into potable water sources. This can result in significant claims exposure for mandatory groundwater cleanup, third-party bodily injury and property damage, and natural resource damages (NRD).

Brine Migration and Reservoir Displacement

High-pressure injection displaces native hypersaline formation water (brine) from deep target reservoirs. Over-pressurization can force this displaced brine upward into overlying drinking water aquifers or surface soils, degrading land and freshwater supplies. Such events can trigger third-party claims for crop loss, land devaluation, and damage to surface property, as well as regulatory enforcement liabilities to restore contaminated water resources.

Surface Atmospheric Releases and Gas Accumulation

Catastrophic failures at wellheads, injection lines, or compressor stations, as well as gradual micro-seeping through topsoil, can release large volumes of CO₂ at the surface. Because CO₂ is an asphyxiant denser than air, it can accumulate on the surface in low-lying areas, posing severe risks to human health and local ecosystems. Operators face liabilities associated with third-party toxic tort or bodily injury claims, emergency response and evacuation costs, and local business interruption damages.

Induced Seismicity and Fault Reactivation

Continuous, large-volume injection increases subsurface pore pressure, which can reactivate dormant geological faults and induce seismic activity. Earthquakes triggered by injection operations can lead to third-party claims for structural property damage to nearby surface buildings and infrastructure. Additionally, secondary faulting can compromise primary reservoir seals, leading to long-term containment failure claims and increased monitoring expenses.

Trace Impurity Releases

CO₂ streams co-captured from industrial facilities often contain trace chemical impurities, such as hydrogen sulfide, sulfur oxides, nitrogen oxides, and heavy metals. Leaks or blowouts involving these streams significantly increase the hazard profile of a release compared to pure CO₂. This elevates an operator’s exposure to acute toxic tort litigation, costly hazardous material cleanup operations, and severe natural resource damage penalties.

Contractors Pollution Liability Can Provide Coverage For

Contracting operations performed at a jobsite

Contracting operations completed “by or on behalf of” the insured

Third-party claims for bodily injury and property damage

Third-party claims for cleanup

Defense of third-party claims

Mold, fungi, legionella, viruses, and bacteria

Sudden and accidental coverage for owned/leased locations

First and third-party transportation pollution liability

Loading and unloading

First-party emergency response costs

Lead and asbestos

Non-owned disposal sites

Claims Scenarios & Examples

A subsurface containment failure occurred at a sequestration site, generating high concentrations of carbonic acid that degraded the well's lower casing strings and cement bond. The acidic fluid migrated upward through the compromised wellbore, breaching the caprock and entering a freshwater aquifer used for municipal drinking water. The contamination elevated heavy metal concentrations and total dissolved solids in local water supplies, forcing emergency municipal well shut-offs and long-term water trucking for three surrounding townships. State environmental authorities required the operator to drill costly remediation wells, while local water authorities and homeowners filed suits that culminated in a $14 million settlement alongside $3.5 million in EPA Safe Drinking Water Act penalties.
A seismic event occurred at a high-volume sequestration facility in Texas when continuous, high-pressure CO₂ injection raised pore pressure beyond geomechanical thresholds, reactivating an unmapped subsurface fault. The resulting earthquake caused widespread structural cracking to nearby residential foundations, ruptured municipal water mains, and damaged surface infrastructure across a three-mile radius. In addition to forcing an immediate regulatory shut-in of the injection well, state energy commissioners mandated an extensive 3D seismic re-survey of the entire formation before operational resumption could be considered. The operating company ultimately paid $6.8 million to settle third-party property damage claims and was fined $950,000 for failing to maintain real-time microseismic monitoring protocols during high-pressure injection cycles.
A wellhead blowout occurred at a carbon capture and injection facility during routine downhole valve maintenance when high-pressure gas unexpectedly sheared blowout preventers. The failure resulted in an uncontrolled, high-velocity release of dense-phase CO₂ containing trace hydrogen sulfide, forming a low-lying asphyxiating cloud that drifted across neighboring agricultural communities. The gas cloud sent four facility technicians to the hospital with acute hypoxia, forced the emergency evacuation of over 1,200 residents, and caused extensive livestock fatalities on adjacent farmland. Following an OSHA and EPA joint investigation, the facility operator agreed to pay $11.5 million in personal injury and property damage settlements and $2.2 million in regulatory fines, and faced severe IRS Section 45Q tax credit clawbacks for the lost, unsequestered emissions.
An expanding subsurface CO₂ pressure plume migrated beyond permitted spatial boundaries and intersected an unrecorded, improperly abandoned historic oil well. The legacy wellbore served as an open conduit, venting dense CO₂ onto a neighboring property while simultaneously pushing displaced formation brine into an adjacent energy company's active mineral estate. The plume encroachment rendered neighboring subsurface pore space unusable and triggered a class-action lawsuit for subsurface trespass and diminution in property value. The storage operator was ordered by state regulators to locate, re-drill, and permanently plug all legacy wells within a two-mile radius at a cost of $5 million, while paying $8.2 million in legal settlements to surrounding landowners and mineral rights holders.

Final Consideration

As a contractor you can be faced with the cost to defend yourself against allegations or legal action from pollution or professional related events, regardless if you are at fault or not. Having the proper insurance coverage in place will help fund the expenses incurred to investigate or defend against a claim or suit and provide you with claims handling expertise.

This environmental risk overview offers a general understanding of potential risks and may not reflect all risks associated with your business. Environmental Risk Professionals has compiled this overview for informational purposes only. This overview does not constitute legal opinion or advice, nor does it establish a consultant-client relationship. This overview is not intended to guide project parties in interpreting specific contracts or resolving disputes; such decisions may require consultation with counsel and depend on various factors. © 2025 Environmental Risk Professionals, LLC

Download PDF